Was there any second in your life once you watched a Kdrama so impressively intriguing when all of a sudden, you felt like one thing was simply off? “Wait, was it speculated to be the Joseon period? Why on the planet was it there?” You’re not the one one who notices the unusual particulars. The truth is, one other Korean historic drama is as soon as once more dealing with controversy for cultural inaccuracy, making the entire “historic” emphasis principally pointless. So, what occurred, and which 2024 Korean historic drama is dealing with such controversy? Allow us to offer you all the small print within the report beneath.
New 2024 Korean Drama Is Going through Sudden Controversy
The controversy surrounding Korean historic drama productions as soon as once more turns into an enormous spotlight with the leaked particulars of the upcoming collection, “The Queen Who Crowns” (a.okay.a. “Received Gyeong”).
On December 19, a leaked poster of “The Queen Who Crowns” began circulating on the web and social media. The poster options Korean rising actress Cha Joo Younger in a dramatic and chic portrayal of her character, Queen Received Gyeong.
On this leaked poster, Cha Joo Younger showcases a wide ranging portrayal of Queen Received Gyeong. Regardless of all of her appearing controversies, her first impression as one of the vital highly effective Queens in Joseon was nothing however distinctive.
The queen is portrayed in a close-up with a somber, intense expression that evokes a way of energy and contemplation. The nice and cozy, golden tones within the background create a comfortable but dramatic distinction, casting shadows that add depth to the composition. On this first impression, Cha Joo Younger efficiently conveyed not simply the great thing about her character but in addition a way of accountability and gravitas, becoming for a queenly position in a historic drama.
But, regardless of all her spectacular portrayals, this new 2024 Korean historic drama nonetheless confronted sudden controversy. Why? Due to the cultural inaccuracy of the costume.
“The Queen Who Crowns” tells the story of Queen Received Gyeong, the spouse of King Taejong Yi Bang Received, the third ruler of South Korea’s historic Joseon dynasty. Nonetheless, when the leaked poster got here out, Cha Joo Younger was sporting a fancy dress with a black halterneck model.
This inaccuracy instantly resulted in an enormous controversy. Followers closely criticized the model, arguing that if it’s set within the Joseon period, historic accuracy must be revered, even in a fictional adaptation.
NOT The First Cultural Inaccuracy Situation
Whereas this subject could seem trivial, it turned large as a result of this isn’t the primary time a Korean historic drama has stirred up controversy over cultural inaccuracies.
“Beneath the Queen’s Umbrella” Bends Joseon’s Guidelines
Beforehand, in 2022, tvN’s “Beneath the Queen’s Umbrella” turned an outstanding collection for its distinctive plot centered round royal princes competing for the throne. Followers extremely liked the contemporary take and the way the collection portrayed a mom’s love from completely different views. Nonetheless, it didn’t escape criticism for bending historic details somewhat too far.
On the time, actress Kim Hye Soo, who portrayed Queen Im Hwa Ryeong, referred to herself as “Bongung.” Apparently, queens throughout the Joseon dynasty by no means used that time period. Therefore, followers who know their historical past had been fast to name it out.
Not solely that, however the drama’s central plot—a rivalry between the queen’s reliable sons and people of royal concubines—additionally raised eyebrows.
Prior to now, beneath the strict Neo-Confucian system of the Joseon period, the queen’s sons (often called Jeoktong Daegun) had been thought of the final word rightful successors. Due to this fact, the concept of concubines’ sons overtly competing for the throne simply didn’t make sense traditionally.
Viewers argued that if the creators needed to inform this type of story, they need to have set it in a fictional kingdom as an alternative. Even fusion historic dramas, it appears, are held to a sure customary of historic accuracy.
“Queen Woo”: Goguryeo or Chinese language?
Furthermore, the controversy doesn’t cease there. Earlier this 12 months, the controversial drama with meaningless intercourse scenes, “Queen Woo,” starring Jeon Jong Search engine optimisation, additionally confronted cultural inaccuracy backlash.
Set within the Goguryeo interval, the costumes worn by the queen appeared far too Chinese language for some viewers’ liking.
Furthermore, from the POV of critics and specialists, all of the costumes’ designs had been reportedly extra impressed by Chinese language dramas than genuine Goguryeo apparel. Due to this fact, this controversy across the phenomenal 2024 Korean historic drama gained robust criticism from a former costume director for the PyeongChang Olympics, Geum Ki Sook.
“While you’re designing one thing fully unfamiliar, creativity is truthful recreation. However when referencing one thing that already exists, that you must be additional cautious.”
Geum Ki Sook.
Between Historic Details and Artistic Exploration: How Far is Too Far?
Lastly, regardless of these dramas being praised for his or her deal with robust feminine leads and daring storytelling, it’s clear that historic inaccuracies can’t simply be brushed apart.
When a drama is about in an actual historic interval, audiences will count on sure requirements to be maintained—significantly with costumes, language, and cultural context. Deviating too far can disrupt immersion and alienate viewers who worth historic loyalty.
Nonetheless, it’s indisputably that creativity is extremely important for contemporary storytelling. Fusion dramas and fictional narratives breathe new life into acquainted histories, permitting for creativeness and relatability.
So, the query is: how far is just too far?
Whereas inventive freedom is essential, respect for historic foundations will undoubtedly root the narrative, enriching each leisure and cultural appreciation. Due to this fact, costumes resembling one other tradition, nonsense storylines, or fashionable parts inserted with out context can truly destroy the credibility of historic references.
Due to this fact, the steadiness truly lies in fastidiously mixing creativeness with authenticity. It’s the way you create a drama that presents a compelling narrative whereas remaining devoted to all the small print and historic references to the previous tradition.
When creators lose this steadiness, even a fascinating story dangers shedding its viewers’s belief.
Do you assume so, too? Please share your ideas within the feedback.
Be a part of us on sondramedia’s Instagram, Threads, Fb, X, Telegram channel, WhatsApp Channel and Discord server for discussions. And observe sondramedia’s Google Information for extra Korean leisure information and updates. You may also be part of our unique membership. You would possibly be capable of be part of our upcoming unique neighborhood occasions and win thrilling prizes!
Supply: TV Report.
Should you like our article and wish each day replace please be part of our neighborhood
